Shawn Robinson
Idealism and The Gun
In the midst of a
heated election to decide the fate of Iowa’s representation in the United
States Senate, Joni Ernst, an Iowa state senator from the small town of Red
Oak, made her beliefs and stance on the second amendment right to carry
firearms well known in the minds of voters, even reaching national headlines
for the severity of her tone. “I have a beautiful little Smith and Wesson, and
it goes with me virtually everywhere” said Ernst at an NRA and Iowa Firearms
Coalition Second Amendment Rally. “I believe in the right to carry, and I
believe in the right to defend myself and my family—whether it’s from an
intruder, or whether it’s from the government, should they decide that my
rights are no longer important”(Source 1). The latter half of the former
Lieutenant Colonel’s statement received the greatest amount of attention,
articles from sites like The Huffington Post highlighting the paradox between
Joni Ernst’s contempt for the federal government she so soon hoped to be
elected to. The Ernst campaign eagerly accepted the attention and furthered her
gun-loving image by releasing a political ad featuring Senator Ernst driving to
a shooting range via motorcycle, where she fires off a round as a narrator
explains, “Joni Ernst will take aim at wasteful spending. And once she sets her
sights on Obamacare, Joni’s gonna[sic] unload”(Source 2). Throughout the
remainder of the campaign, Ernst definitively portrayed herself as a personal
gun advocate, a passionate voice against the ambiguous, and unfounded, threat
of the current administration suspending the rights of the American citizens to
bear arms, and as an undoubtedly extreme figure in American politics. On
November 4th, the people of Iowa let their civic voice be heard, voting
Joni Ernst into national office for the next six years. As with every national
election, the results speak volumes of the country’s political climate. While
many factors inarguably contributed to Joni Ernst’s selection as Iowa’s
representative, her self-presentation makes it difficult to separate the
candidate from her values towards firearms, showing the majority of Iowans
desire less strict gun regulation.
This is hardly
surprising, seeing as how a 2011 Gallup poll found through a national survey that
“support for stricter gun control laws has steadily decreased, dropping from
78% to 44% since 1990”(Source 8). Obviously, there are various reasons why the
American public struggles with and rejects the idea of gun control, the few
most popular of which will be addressed and represented as accurately as
possible, and the issue is one that has garnered political attention throughout
the country’s history, Joni Ernst just the newest face on an issue as old as
any the United States has faced.
This paper offers
a solution in the form of an ideal, an American society in which no civilian
carries firearms, in pursuit of another ideal, a non-violent and generally
peaceful country. As with most ideals, it goes without saying that these two
goals will never be realistically attained, whether separately or together. The
citizens of the United States will always carry firearms and, in consequence,
the United States will never be a non-violent or generally peaceful place. With
admission to this, what follows is justification for why banning guns in
America would benefit our country, if the theoretical were to be put into
practice.
First, though, the
varying concerns raised by any and all in support of firearms must be
addressed. While arguments against gun control are more or less equally valid,
there may be no better place to start than with the second amendment right to
bear arms. Word for word, the amendment reads, “A well regulated militia being
necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear
arms shall not be infringed”(Source Const). This right was further elaborated
on by James Madison, co-author of the Constitution, in Federalist Paper 46,
where the notion of armed militias is used to refute any fears of a military
coup in the newly formed country. These writings also form the back bone of
Joni Ersnt’s argument, her promise to defend herself from even “the government,
should they decide [her] rights are no longer important” harkening directly
back to the original intent of the founding fathers. It is, in a sense, the
most fundamental social contract and system of check and balance in American
society: the government can do as it pleases, so long as the freedom of the
people is not imposed upon. Otherwise, the proven revolutionaries would take up
arms in search of liberty yet again.
For many in the
modern age, though, the concern is less combative in nature and more personal
in scope. A 2005 nationwide Gallup poll found that for 67% of Americans, their
reason for owning firearms was for protection against crime (Source 5). This,
along with the fear that criminals would maintain their current stock of
weapons and only honest citizens would truly be restricted, makes the idea of
gun control seem foolish to some Americans. For themselves, their loved ones,
and their friends, these Americans see firearms as security and safety.
Then there are
those who merely use firearms as a mode of sport, recreation, or entertainment.
Whether it be at the shooting range, as Joni Ernst was in her TV ad, in a
forest hunting wild game, or out on a piece of private property, testing aim by
shooting cans, a large number of Americans look to guns as a source of release
and pleasure. The same Gallup poll from 2005 also found that 66% of gun owners
mentioned target shooting as a reason for ownership and 58% mentioned hunting
(Source 5). These gun owners probably acknowledge the threat that exists from
the presence of their weapons, but many would also probably argue that the
knife poses similar concerns of danger, yet still is a tool of great productive
and essential use when handled responsibly, and that guns can be and should be
treated likewise. Some hunters would even argue that wildlife populations would
become an environmental and communal hazard should their numbers not be
regulated.
Without question,
further arguments for the preservation of firearms in our society exist, but
the aforementioned are statistically noted to be the central reasoning and
criteria by which the common gun owner stands.
All are powerful and sound in their own right and all are equally
invalid and vulnerable to definitive rebuttal in light of the previously stated
ideal that no citizen should own firearms.
First, the
unconstitutional grounds on which the ideal itself stands must be addressed.
There is no debate on whether or not the right to bear arms is explicitly
guaranteed by the United States Constitution. What is debatable, though, is the
fallibility of the Constitution. The flaws in the original governing document
have been acknowledged so often to the point of becoming trite, yet they remain
just as undeniable as when initially commented upon. The most popular
reflections of the Constitution’s imperfections are Article IV, Section 2,
Clause 3 and Amendment 18. Article IV, Section 2, Clause 3, more commonly
referred to as the fugitive slave clause, sets forth the edict that a slave
fleeing from the south shall constitutionally be required to return to their
state of origin and ownership. The more recent eighteenth amendment, which
began prohibition in America, is equally as infamous for its utter failure to
effectively govern as intended. These are just popular examples and instances
of the humanity of the founding fathers and the leaders who followed in their
footsteps, which is often lost in their glorification and the adoration of
their governing document. Truly, these were brilliant men, but men all the
same, capable and guilty of flaws and limitations. Furthermore, what once could
have been a cunning measure of government can become outdated after centuries,
as is the case with the second amendment right to bear arms. Contrary to the
beliefs of Joni Ernst and countless more around the nation, a citizen formed
militia, regardless of size or valor, would stand no realistic chance at
defeating the United States military. Militaristic advancement and
sophistication has significantly changed in the time since James Madison
originally spoke to the value of militias in the Federalist Papers. It is both
puzzling and alarming that so many Americans pride themselves on having the
most powerful military in the world, yet still believe in the false presumption
that untrained civilians could defeat said military should the need arise.
Next comes the
overarching concern that gun control will lead to less safe communities and
more vulnerable citizens. After all, protection was found to be the primary
reason Americans possess firearms. It must be noted that, while the raw
research on the effectiveness of gun control is highly abundant, the search for
concrete, objective evidence is one that limits the applicable documents
significantly. Part of what has allowed the debate on firearms to perpetuate
itself forward for so long is this lack of credible information. No matter
where one might stand on the issue, there is data that will justify their
argument. This paper attempts to remedy any concerns of partisan corruption
though the use of the most neutral source and relevant statistics available,
which come from the Harvard Injury Control Research Center, an organization
with nothing to gain or lose from the presentation of accurate facts. The
Harvard Injury Control Research Center states that, “Case-control studies,
ecological time-series and cross-sectional studies indicate that in homes, cities,
states, and regions in the U.S., where there are more guns, both men and women
are at higher risk for homicide, particularly firearm homicide”(Source 7). In
the same report, they go on to say “States with higher levels of household gun
ownership had higher rates of firearm homicide and overall homicide” (Source
7). This report only confirms, what for many is an intuitive point of
understanding, that where there exists more lethal weapons, there will be more
deaths. Other even broader constructs of this philosophy of futility would be
that an eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind, or that fighting fire with
fire merely spreads the flames. The question may be raised, in light of these
statements assuring the harm and negative presence of firearms within
communities, why the issue of firearms remains so heavily debated and two-sided
in America, and why, as the 2011 Gallup poll revealed, support for gun control
is actually steadily decreasing (Source 8)? While the full reasoning is most
certainly too complex to explain in any number of words, a large contribution
to understanding could be the fact that from the 1990 election cycle through
August 22nd, 2010, twenty-two million dollars had been spent by gun
rights activists on federal candidates and elections, with only one million
dollars having been spent by gun control supporters in the same period of time
(Source 5). With greater funding comes more publicity, allowing irrational
fears and false ideas to persist alongside the reasonable and logical.
Even if firearms
do pose an eminent threat to the public, the notion of the hunter and hobbyist
gun owner still remains untouched. In such environments where the intent of the
gun is not violence, at least not towards another person, why should firearms
be banned? Answered bluntly, because their variable existence within American
civilian society to any extent complicates the matter of enforcing a general
ban and raises the risk of injury due to accident. Just as other dangerous and
lethal explosives are not given special pardoning for their owner’s intentions
of using them in a recreational atmosphere, so to should firearms be treated.
If hunters and shooting range aficionados legitimately crave the thrill of
precise projectile targeting, one would find difficulty in claiming that
archery does not offer the same pleasures, and at the same time requires more
skill, making it an even more valid sport. If the difficulty of archery over a
gun perseveres as a complaint from gun activists, this paper has nothing to
offer other than the comment that personal laziness should not subject the
general public to greater danger. Lastly, to address the concern of animal
populations becoming unmanageable, one may make the observation that an animal
dies from an arrow entering them, too.
Through all the
disdain and animosity many surely will find with the ideas presented in this
paper, common ground is never far from reach. That common ground rests on the
known truth that, however heated and polarizing the arguments may be, both
sides of it are ultimately in pursuit of the same ideal, a safe and peaceful
America. No one can deny that the current state of the country is not one of
peace. As The Washington Post reports, “Since 1982, there have been at least 61
mass murders carried out with firearms across the country, with the killings
unfolding in 30 states from Massachusetts to Hawaii…And in most cases, the killers
had obtained their weapons legally”(Source 6). To put the same reality of
violence in an international light, The Washington Post goes on to explain that
“15 of the 25 most severe mass shootings in the last 50 years took place in the
United States”(Source 6). It should also be mentioned that Finland, a country
fondly referenced by gun activists as an example of a nation with a high level
of gun ownership and low crime rates, is responsible for the second most of
these 25 most severe shootings. Past all the falsifications, pre-developed
opinions, and pride, the reality of violence lingers. Putting such poisons to
constructive progress aside, one must admit the current system is not working
and that all available and reliable evidence suggests a system with lower
restrictions would only lead to greater violence. Thus, this paper presents an
alternative. An ideal. A world without guns and the destruction they cause. A
charming and logical path to peace. And still, no less of an impossibility.
Work Cited
Source 5 = http://www.justfacts.com/guncontrol.asp